Skip to content

Best Eyeshadow Primer for a Night Out

Step out in style with the best eyeshadow primer - it'll keep your makeup looking fresh all night long and give your lids a beautiful shimmery boost!

11 min read
Photo-Illustration: Catchy Shopper; Photos: Retailers

In This Article

This post may contain affiliate links, please see our privacy policy for details.

Getting ready for a night out can be a daunting task, especially when it comes to perfecting your makeup. Have you ever applied your eyeshadow only for it to start creasing or fading as the night goes on? Well, we have the solution for you – eye primers!

Eye primers are the key to making sure your eyeshadow, liner and mascara stay in place all night long. But with so many different kinds of eye primers on the market, how do you know which one is the best choice for a night out?

We’re taking a look at some of the best eyeshadow primers around and giving you all the information you need to pick the perfect one for your needs.

What is an Eyeshadow Primer?

An eyeshadow primer is a product used to prepare eyelids for makeup application. It increases the longevity of eye shadow, extends its wear, and prevents creasing and fading throughout the day.  Primers can also help smooth out any uneven lines or skin texture, creating a flawless base for your eye makeup.

In addition to eyeshadow primers, some brands offer similar products specifically made for eyeliners and mascaras that work to prevent smudging and caking while keeping them true-to-color all day long.

How We Choose

Choosing the best eyeshadow primer for a night out doesn't have to be an overwhelming task. With the right information and some careful consideration, you can find the perfect one for your needs. When it comes to choosing the best eyeshadow primer, we take a few things into consideration.

First, we look at the ingredients list to make sure it's made with quality ingredients that we know and trust.

Second, we read reviews from other customers to get an idea of how it works in real life.

Third, we try it out for ourselves to see how it feels on our skin and how well it works with our other makeup products.

No matter what type of look you're going for – classic or trendy – investing in a good eyeshadow primer is key for making sure your makeup looks flawless all night long.

With so many different primers available, you can find one that not only fits your needs but also complements your individual style!

Best Eyeshadow Primer to Prevent Oily Lids

We love Elizabeth Mott's Thank Me Later Eye Primer for its ability to give your lids the ultimate foundation for eye makeup and for helping to enhance the pigment of your eyeshadow. This primer is paraben-free, cruelty-free, and Leaping Bunny-approved, so you can trust that it's made from high-quality ingredients like pearl powder.

The formula is a well-balanced one that's weightless and non-greasy so you won't feel any heaviness around your eyes or need constant touchups. It does double duty by evening out skin tone and fighting oiliness and creasing, leaving you with smoother skin and a more balanced complexion.

Whether you're going for a classic or trendy look, investing in a good eyeshadow primer is key for making sure your makeup looks flawless all night long. You can thank us later after trying this amazing primer!

Best Non-Drying Eyeshadow Primer

We love Revlon's ColorStay Eye Shadow Primer for creating vibrant, crease-free eye shadows that will last all day. The unique formula is crafted with a shea butter care complex that provides a lightweight and smooth surface for application. It blends easily and won't dry or cake your complexion, so you can trust it to look great on all skin tones.

What's more, this primer features ColorStay technology that helps lock in color for up to 24 hours without the need for frequent touchups. Its universal shade makes it easy to apply, making it a great companion to the Revlon Color Stay Eye Collection. Plus, you can trust Revlon's long-standing reputation as a trendsetter in the world of cosmetics that delivers high-quality products at affordable prices.

Best Long-Lasting Eyeshadow Primer

Milani's Eyeshadow Primer is one of the best eyelid primers on the market. This lightweight and crease-proof formula help intensify the color of your eyeshadow, making it last from day to night. It glides on clear, so you can trust that your eye shadow will have a professional and smooth finish without any dryness or caking.

Plus, it's vegan, cruelty-free, and made for long-lasting wear. Not only does this primer make your favorite palettes pop with color, but it also demonstrates Milani's commitment to diversity and inclusion by providing makeup for every shade, attitude, and ethnicity. So go ahead - add a little extra love to your look with Milani Eyeshadow Primer!

Best Smoothening Eyeshadow Primer

We love Benefit Cosmetics Stay Don't Stray Eye Makeup Primer for its dual-action formula that can be applied to both the eyelids and under-eye crease. This tinted primer creates a shield over eyeshadow to help it last through your day, while also eliminating discoloration and giving you a more nuanced texture.

Plus, the doe foot applicator makes application easy, so you're always camera ready. And thanks to vitamins C & E hydrating sodium hyaluronate, and 360° coverage around your eyes - you can trust your concealers and eyeshadows will stay vibrant and creaseless no matter where the night takes you. With only one color sans strong peach or pink tones, this matte finish is sure to work with every skin tone.

Best Satin-Finished Eyeshadow Primer

NYX Professional Makeup Eyeshadow Base Primer is a beauty staple you don't want to miss. This cream-based eye primer comes in three colors: white, pearl, and skin tone - each offering different effects for your makeup look. The white shade intensifies your eyeshadow color up to 100x more visibly, the pearl helps maximize any iridescent effect, while the skin tone creates a natural hold to your desired look.

As if that's not enough, this primer also helps colors last longer throughout the day, giving you that fresh-out-of-the-makeup chair feeling. And if you're an animal lover like us; NYX is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free brand – so no animals were harmed during the production of their products! Let the NYX Professional Makeup Eyeshadow Base Primer add awesome colors and lasting wear to your look!

Best Eyeshadow Primer for Oily Eyelids

We love Urban Decay Anti-Aging Eyeshadow Primer Potion for its dual benefits - to make your eyeshadows last longer while aiding in the prevention of wrinkles. This primer improves upon the signs of aging, leaving your eyelids visibly smoother and making it easier to apply perfect eyeshadow application. Its light-as-air formula won't feel heavy on the skin and helps ensure an intense, long-lasting eyeshadow color payoff.

Plus, with ingredients like Dermaxyl (which helps smoothen out wrinkles) and Kalpariane (which improves suppleness and elasticity), it's an essential beauty product you don't want to miss. And just when you thought that was it – this primer also brightens your eye area with a creamy texture, even if at first it might feel a little tacky. So don't worry; once it's dried down you won't be able to tell it's there but will be able to appreciate amazing staying power all day!

Best Eyeshadow Primer for All-Day Wear

Get ready to make lasting memories with COVERGIRL Lid Lock Up Eyeshadow Primer! This eye makeup primer is perfect for anyone looking to keep their eyeshadow lasting all day. The formula is quick-drying and water-resistant, ensuring your shadow won't smudge or rub off - no matter how long your day may be. And with the easy applicator tip, you can dab on just the right amount of product - helping you start your makeup routine in full swing.

But that's not all; this eye makeup primer locks in color and prevents creasing instantly, meaning you don't have to worry about wrinkles appearing throughout your day either. On top of that, as an added bonus all COVERGIRL products are Leaping Bunny Certified – so no animals were harmed during production! Let COVERGIRL Lid Lock Up Eyeshadow Primer be a part of your beauty routine today.

Best Waterproof Eyeshadow Primer

The Ownest 3 Colors Eyeshadow Makeup Primer has a light consistency that is easy to apply and blend into your skin. This primer comes in six shades – white, medium, dark, violet, mint green, and rose pink – so you can always find a shade to match your exact skin color. This primer dries quickly, creates a smooth surface on the skin, and has great oil-control properties which prevent your eye makeup from creasing or fading throughout the day. It also contains natural moisturizing ingredients that help even out skin tone and reduces fine lines and pores.

One of the most important features of this product is its ability to lock in your eyeshadow color and keep it looking vibrant all day long. Plus, it takes just a few seconds for it to dry after application and allows for an effortless blending of shadows with no wrinkles in sight! Whether you’re going for an everyday look or something more dramatic for special occasions, this primer is sure to give you the perfect base for your eye makeup every time.

Best Vegan Eyeshadow Primer

MILK Makeup Hydro Grip Eye Primer always provides unbeatable results that last up to 8 hours. This invisible eye primer is perfect for helping you create a smooth, even canvas before applying any eyeshadows or concealers. Plus, it contains natural ingredients and is vegan, clean, cruelty-free, paraben-free, oil-free, alcohol-free, silicone-free, fragrance-free, and gluten-free!

This product can be applied under the eyes or on eyelids using an angled doe foot applicator or fingertips and helps blur fine lines and wrinkles around the eyes for a youthful appearance. Once applied it locks down color so you can be sure that your look will stay intact until you take it off. It's also quick drying so no need to wait around for ages for your face to set! Whether you’re looking for an everyday primer or something more intense for special occasions; this product comes highly recommended!

Best Silicone Based Eyeshadow Primer

We love Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow Primer for its reliable performance that never fails to deliver. This silicone-based eye shadow primer helps create a smooth base before applying your eyeshadow, locks down color, and can last up to 24+ hours without smudging or creasing! The skin-soothing formula evens out the skin tone on your lids while also protecting you from any harmful blue light.

Moreover, it is formulated with an essential blend of skin-loving ingredients, plus an easy-blend doe-foot wand for seamless application. This eye primer is perfect for all occasions and comes highly recommended for anyone looking for a fuss-free application experience that delivers professional results every time!

Best Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base Primer

We love NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base for its unbeatable performance that ensures a long-lasting look with no smudging, creasing, or caking. This lightweight primer prepares your eye area for cream or powder eye color and helps keep your makeup looking fresh and brilliant all day long!

Its blend of polymer and mineral powder helps to extend the wear of eyeshadow, eyeliner & eyebrow pencils while providing a firm grip on color without it smudging. Plus, it is fortified with a special deep-sea extract & an antioxidant rice extract so it instantly dries and leaves delicate eyelids feeling smooth.

This product is dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested and is completely fragrance-free, making it a great option for anyone with sensitive skin. Highly recommended!

Best Eyeshadow Primers FAQs

To answer all questions and more, we've put together this FAQ guide about best eyeshadow primers. Here, we'll take a look at some of the most commonly asked questions so that you can find just what you need with ease!

What does eyeshadow primer do?

An eyeshadow primer is a product that you apply to your eyelids before eyeshadow, in order to create a smooth, even surface for the shadow to adhere to. Primers can also help eyeshadow to last longer and prevent creasing.

What are the benefits of an eyeshadow primer?

An eyeshadow primer can help to create a smooth, even base for your eyeshadow, making it easier to apply and helping it to last longer. It can also help to intensify the color of your eyeshadow and make it more vibrant.

What is the difference between eye primer and eyeshadow primer?

Eyeshadow primer and eye primer are both products that are designed to help your makeup last longer and look better. However, there are some key differences between the two.

For one, eyeshadow primer is typically lighter in consistency than eye primer. This is because it needs to be able to adhere to your eyelids without being too heavy.

What is the best eyeshadow primer for mature eyes?

There are a few things to consider when choosing an eyeshadow primer for mature eyes. First, you want to make sure the primer is hydrating, as mature skin can be drier.

Second, you want to choose a primer with light-reflecting properties to help minimize the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles.

Third, you want to make sure the primer has good staying power so your eyeshadow will last all day.

How do you apply an eyeshadow primer?

There are a few different ways to apply an eyeshadow primer, depending on the formula. If you're using a liquid or cream primer, you can apply it with your fingers or with a brush.

If you're using a powder primer, you can either press it into your skin with your fingers or use a brush to apply it. Once you've applied the primer, you can then apply your eyeshadow as usual.

Do you put powder after eye primer?

There's no right or wrong answer to this question - it's entirely up to personal preference. Some people find that applying powder after eye primer helps to set the primer and prevent creasing, while others prefer to skip the powder step altogether. Experiment and see what works best for you!

Do you put eyeshadow primer on before or after the foundation?

Foundation should always be applied before eyeshadow primer. This will help to create a smooth, even surface on which to apply your eyeshadow. If you apply eyeshadow primer first, it may end up looking patchy.

Should you let eye primer dry before applying eyeshadow?

Yes, you should let eye primer dry before applying eyeshadow. If you don't, the eyeshadow won't adhere as well and will be more likely to crease.

Final Thoughts

Overall, finding the very best eyeshadow primers for your needs can be a daunting task. That's why we've done all the hard work and put together this comprehensive guide to help you find exactly what you're looking for! We’ve highlighted some of our top picks that are sure to give you long-lasting results with minimal effort. Whether it’s MILK MAKEUP Hydro Grip Eye Primer with a concealer primer, Too Faced Eye Shadow Primer, or NARS Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base; these primers will provide unbeatable performance so that your eye makeup looks perfect every time. So go ahead and pick one (or more!) of these amazing products today -you won't regret it!